2053 Woodbridge Avenue - Edison, NJ 08817

Tuesday, April 17, 2018

E536 ndex 1. Recent cases: GPS tracking device by police not barred. 2. NJ had jurisdiction for criminal spam attack on NJ business 3. OPRA can also require electronically stored data. 4. Non-running Community events 5. Fun Upcoming Charity Running Races

Kenneth Vercammen, Attorney at Law 
March 6, 2018
1. Recent cases:  GPS tracking device by police not barred.  
2. NJ had jurisdiction for criminal spam attack on NJ business 
3. OPRA can also require electronically stored data. 
4. Non-running Community events 
5. Fun Upcoming Charity Running Races 

1. GPS tracking device by police not barred State v McDuffie 450 NJ Super. 554 (App. Div. 2017).
   The court examined defendants' attack on the State's exercised privilege, refraining from disclosing information regarding details related to a global positioning system (GPS) tracking device used to prove their involvement in two burglaries. The court rejected defendants' constitutional attacks and upheld the privilege granted by N.J.R.E. 516 and N.J.S.A. 2A:84A-28, defining the guidelines reviewed when weighing disclosure in light of the asserted privilege.
These include: (1) whether defendant demonstrates a particularized need for disclosure related to advance a stated defense; (2) whether the opportunity to cross-examine the officer, asserting non-disclosure based on privilege, satisfies a defendant's need to challenge the credibility of the testifying witness; (3) whether law enforcement provided required corroborating evidence extrinsic to the GPS, to protect a defendant's rights of confrontation and fair trial; and (4) whether a defendant has the opportunity to provide expert testimony to attack the evidence without disclosure of the requested information. Docket A-3634-14T3

2. NJ had jurisdiction for criminal spam attack on NJ business. State v Tringali 451 NJ Super. 18 (App. Div. 2017).
    The State alleged that, acting in Florida, defendant paid an accomplice to launch spam attacks on a website that was integral to a New Jersey internet-based business, for the purpose of harming the business owner.
   The Appellate Division reversed an order dismissing the indictment charging defendant with the offenses of disrupting or impairing computer services, N.J.S.A. 2C:20-25(b), and impersonating another for the purpose of obtaining a benefit or depriving another of a benefit, N.J.S.A. 2C:21-17(a)(1). As to both offenses, the harmful result to the victim is an "element" of the offense, within the meaning of the territorial jurisdiction statute, N.J.S.A. 2C:1-3(a)(1) and -3(g).
     Because the prosecutor produced some evidence that the New Jersey victims suffered harm in this State, which was an element of each computer crime statute, New Jersey has territorial jurisdiction to prosecute defendant for those offenses. Therefore, the trial court erred in dismissing those counts of the indictment for lack of territorial jurisdiction. A-1262-15T1

3. OPRA can also require electronically stored data. Paff v. Galloway Township 229 NJ 340 (2017).
   The Appellate Division's overly constrictive reading of OPRA cannot be squared with the OPRA's objectives or statutory language. OPRA recognizes that government records will constitute not only paper documents, but also information electronically stored.
   The fields of information covering "sender," "recipient," "date," and "subject" in the emails sent by the Galloway Township Chief of Police and Clerk over a two-week period are government records under OPRA.

March 16, 2018 Highland Park Office of Aging at 11am Wills & Estates Free program

March 18, 2018 South Amboy Parade Sunday at 1 PM.

March 18, 2018 Elks Citizen of the Year Awards Dinner Central District held at Carteret Elks Ken V is current Edison Citizen of the Year

March 22 2018, Middlesex County Bar Awards Dinner at The Pines Manor in Edison. [Ken V is a past winner of Municipal Court Attorney of the Year]

March 24, 2018 Highlands Saint Patrick's Day Parade   2pm park near Central, go to Claddagh, then Inlet Cafe

March 25, 2018 Keyport, NJ St. Patrick's Day Parade
Saturday, Kick-off will be at 1:00 PM

March 18, 2018 St. Paddy's 5 mile   9:30 Freehold  great FARC event Dress warm. FARC is a 501(c) 3 not for profit organization. which typically donate over $25,000 each year to local charities.

March 24, 2018  Jersey Shore Kilt Run / Walk (Lake Como) 11 am
 Great event by JerseyRunner.com & Gio Dr. T-shirtjerseyrunner.com Wakefern Shoprite co-sponsor

Editorial Assistance provided by Meriam Kahany. Ms. Kahany is currently attending Rutgers University and is participating in Kenneth Vercammen's Spring Law Office Volunteer Internship Program.

Like Us On: Facebook

Endorse Us On: Linkedin  
Editor's Note and Disclaimer:
All materials Copyright 2018. You may pass along the information on the NJ Laws Newsletter and website, provided the name and address of the Law Office is included.